Fri 20 May 2011
So it’s harmless, right, to label a wine Bitch. Or Sexy Bitch or Sweet Bitch or Royal Bitch or Crazy Bitch or any other of the 48 “bitch”
names for which producers or marketers have applied to the TTB (common shorthand for the Federal Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau) that oversees and approves labels for alcoholic beverages in the U.S.
I mean this is all just a joke, right, and if I am increasingly bothered by the proliferation of such “humorous” bitch labels then I must be a prude or completely lacking in sense of humor or just plain old, because the bitch labels, the critter labels, the goofy labels, the surreal labels, the double ententre labels — Pinot Evil, Herding Cats, Plungerhead, Screw Kappa Napa, Rude Boy and Rude Girl, Hair of the
Dingo, Full Montepulciano, Smoking Parrot, Arrogant Frog and on and on — are intended, we are told, to draw the attention of young people who (quoting a press release) “are intrigued by fun wines freed of the burden of snobbery and geeky Old School connoisseurship.”
Actually, I’m not a prude, and I have a pretty active and slightly bent sense of humor — I won’t comment on the age issue — but words have meanings and consequences, and I think that the “bitch” label phenomenon — apparently launched by the R Winery in Australia, a
collaboration between winemaker Chris Ringland and American importer Dan Philips that ran into serious financial trouble last year — offers a serious critique on attitudes toward women in America.
What is a bitch? A female dog, to be sure. Also a complaining woman; a competitive woman; a woman with a superior attitude; a demanding or assertive woman; a woman who denies a man sex; in short — women, because to many segments of American culture, all women are competitive, demanding, assertive, balls-breaking bitches. Unless, of course, they manifest the other side of femininity, promulgated in mainstream Hollywood movies and television sit-coms, as the sweet, non-threatening girls you would be proud to take home to meet Mom and Dad. (Maybe not Dad.) Hiphop, one of the dominant if not the dominant form of pop music in America (and an incredible influence on world culture), is defined by its deeply misogynist stance on women. Who hasn’t stopped at a red light next to a thunderously booming sound system that you feel in the marrow of your defenseless bones that churns out the refrains of “Slap the bitch,” “Fuck the bitch” and “Kill the bitch”?
Whatever advances were attained by women and their male supporters in the 1960s, 70s and 80s, popular culture has succeeded in dumbing down or, at least in the collective imagination, turning into a charade, a caricature of progress. Look at the two women involved in the latest public displays of unhinged male prowess, the still-unnamed chambermaid assaulted in a New York hotel — excuse me, allegedly assaulted — by IMF director Dominque Strass-Kahn, and Mildred Patricia Baena, the housekeeper who worked for Arnold Schwarzenegger and Maria Shriver for 20 years and who after an affair with Schwarzenegger gave birth to his child in 1997. Both women are being demonized on websites and blogs all over the world, the maid for daring to accuse a man far her superior in wealth, status and importance, and Baena for not being hot enough. Like, who do these gold-digging bitches think they are?
There’s nothing wrong with humor and irreverence in the naming of wines and the design of their labels; if irreverence and creativity bring more people into the wine-drinking fold, I’m all for it. Do we, however, have to continue to demean women in such automatic, casual, degrading manner? Let’s have a moratorium on “bitch”‘ labels. Let’s be better than that.
Bitch Grenache image, slightly altered, from aglassafterwork.com
May 20th, 2011 at 4:03 pm
Fredric,
I got a pair of the Australian Bitch wines as a gift a while back, and despite the amusing packaging the wine was awful. Yet a lot of my female friends in the 20s-30s age range find the whole thing hilarious, and a lot of them have bought bottles just to keep around as decorations. It’s really popular with baby showers/wedding showers/divorce parties/etc.
And to add to your list of transgressors, I once sampled a Middle Tennessee wine called “Big Bitch Red”.
I’d love to see a wine themed with Baroness Thatcher, perhaps a stainless steel fermented Chardonnay called “The Iron Lady”, or an aggressive Italian wine with the title “Virago” for the fact that .05% of the population would chuckle at the title. But I’m with you on the label issue. I’m not a prude but I prefer that wine labels not feature profanity or nudity or denigrations of any form. It’s not that it bothers me so much as I think it demeans the industry and the hobby. Wine is food, and I don’t need to be encouraged to purchase zucchini with cheap dick jokes.
Cheers,
Benito
May 20th, 2011 at 6:42 pm
My wine shop owning friend Jill Ditmire in Indianapolis tells me she can’t keep Bitch or Bitch Bubbly on the shelf when it’s available. Gals love it, populating many a bachelorette party, mother in law birthday, BFF gift with a bottle. Married twice, father of three daughters, I gave up long ago trying to gain deeper understandings of my female friends. When I worked with Dan & Chris I can’t tell you the number of emails, letters, photos and more that came into the office, all complimentary, all expressions of thanks and devotion. Unlike Benito, I found the Grenache to be a solid QPR most of the time. Now sourced from Spain instead of Australia, I have a feeling that 60,000+ cases annually speaks fairly loudly, and I’ll bet 59,999 of them are purchased by Babes In Total Control of Herself, which was Dan’s whimsical explanation. Grateful Palate lives on, in all it’s glory and irreverence.
May 21st, 2011 at 12:35 am
We have wine stores here in our area but I cant find these bitch wines.
May 21st, 2011 at 7:51 am
While not a fan of jammy fruit bombs myself (like Bitch)…I must say that the sentiment F.Koeppel expresses is a joke. When will we begin to focus on truly serious problems. I have sold many humorously named wines like Bitch, Royal Bitch, etc. And although it doesn’t fit the above narrative…I take no offense to “Fat Bastard” wines. Grow up!
May 22nd, 2011 at 7:22 am
I totally agree with the sentiment expressed in the article.
May 22nd, 2011 at 12:40 pm
Surprisingly good wine (Australian Bitch), but seriously, this really does need to be reviewed. There is no reason for wine to go trashy.
May 22nd, 2011 at 8:52 pm
Fredric, You are right. People forget that words have meaning, and that the use of words can have subtle but detrimental effects on how people think and perceive.
May 22nd, 2011 at 10:59 pm
The story I heard behind the “Bitch” line of wines (which include the labels “Evil” and “Pure Evil”) was that the deteriorating relationships between the former partners lead to the formation of the labels as a comment on the state of things between them. So any denigration intended in this instance is most likely particular to this set of circumstances, and not intended in general terms.
Selling it at retail, I can only say that ther were *huge* sales at Mother’s Day, usually from younger daughters, who would grab a bottle, giggle and comment, “Mom will love this! She’s got a great sense of humor!” I could only smile and say, “I certainly hope so…”
May 23rd, 2011 at 1:43 am
I say let’s take the word ‘bitch’ back! I mean if people can dropped the n-bomb and the c-bomb and the mf-bomb all they want and they can have meanings ranging from the terrible to the endearing. Why not all us bitches over use the word so it loses it’s meaning forever! I have worked in bars around the world and the b-bomb gets dropped like it’s hot, but it’s not. Only women can make something hot so let’s make it hot! Haaha this is fun. I love wine bitches!
May 23rd, 2011 at 7:17 am
A label with a close-up of a resting hounddog’s face with the word BITCH emblazoned on it is probably next.
That would totally rule, by the way.
July 17th, 2011 at 7:49 am
This discussion concerning the “Bitch” wines caught me off guard, it reminds me of Hollywood caring about “R” rating or NC-17: when society or a significant fragment of that society has no “real” basis for moral order then that society must take the whole package of immorality, or just dabble in self-righteousness.
Fredric Koeppel’s higher standard, though commendable, is spitting against the wind on Mount Washington, and, I might add, that the Existentialist would commend him also.
I’ve been preparing to do a Halloween-party collection of wines and to review them; what I’ve found is nothing short of hedonistic-neo-paganism that should give “Rosemary’s baby” leaps of joy.
“Bitch” or “Bitches Brew” resigns me (sadly) to the reality of the culture we live in, joining them in dabbling around the edges just amuses me in my despair of apathy.
Sincerely,
Dennis Tsiorbas
November 4th, 2011 at 11:20 pm
I see no problem with it. As a 25 year old female I have been called a bitch plenty of times. To me it means being able to stand up for myself and not “needing” a man to protect me. It means taking care myself and doing what I need to do.If this makes me a bitch so be it. Bitch was not supposed to be a negative word, just an unspayed female dog. Why we feel the need to turn everything into a derogatory word is beyond me
November 14th, 2011 at 4:59 am
For the record!
http://happybitchwines.com/
November 19th, 2011 at 5:45 am
From Click Orlando:The “You & Me Interactive Triplets,” which are being sold at Toys R Us stores in Orlando, are causing the uproar because one of the dolls can be heard saying what appears to be the phrase, “Hey, crazy bitch.”
Just thought this might keep the drama going! Me bad!