Fri 11 Jan 2008
What a relief to drink a nice, clean, fresh, crisp Saint-Véran after the California white wines I’ve been trying for the past week. I don’t mean just chardonnays, the dead horse that I flog relentlessly, because most white wines from California tend to be bigger, bolder and brighter than their European counterparts, and I’m talking about the examples that I like.
I was fortunate, for example, to taste more white Burgundies than usual last year, mainly from 2004 and 2005, and no matter how rich they were, no matter how deep and layered and textured, none of them was over-wrought, none of them was sodden with the excessive oak and tropical fruit and dessert-like flavors that make many chardonnays from California so cloying that they’re undrinkable. And those are the kinds of wines — at least some of them — that I tried last week, though there were also a few that were beautifully, impeccably made, by which I mean, naturally, that they displayed perfect balance among all elements: fruit, acid, oak; flavor, texture, structure. You can read reviews of 12 California white wines — ratings vary from Excellent to Avoid — here.
Anyway, as I was saying, after some of these hard-hitting white wines, it was almost thrilling to drink a bottle of the Domaine
Perraud Saint-Véran Vieilles Vignes 2005 with a simple Italian chicken soup with pasta, spinach and Parmesan cheese and a beaten egg whipped into each bowl. I guess that qualifies as Italian egg-drop soup. The wine combined many elements of lemon — fresh lemon with touches of roasted lemon and lemon curd — along with a hint of jasmine, a touch of spice and loads of limestone that practically vibrated from the vigorous acid that kept the whole package taut and lively. I immediately want to take back the word “taut,” though, because that makes it sound as if the wine were not also dense and smooth and silky, which it certainly was, the point being that as with most enjoyable white wines the slight tug-of-war between crispness and density was exhilarating. This is the second bottle of the Perraud V.V. Saint-Veran ‘05 that we’ve had in three months, and both times it was delightful. North Berkeley Imports, Berkeley, Ca. I rate it Very Good+. About $18-$20.
Here are two more wines from Saint-Véran that I tried last night.
The Saint-Véran 2006 from the Cave de Prissé delivers a bouquet that you want to swim in or dab behind your ears. Apple, pear
and lemon, lime peel, limestone and jasmine and a touch of smoke combine for a boundlessly appealing beginning for this wine. It’s crisp and lively and notably earthy and minerally, with roasted lemon and grapefruit flavors set into a bracing and austere limestone and shale structure. In the mouth, actually, this Saint-Véran doesn’t quite live up to the promise of its bouquet, but it’s still an attractive and tasty accompaniment to grilled fish and fresh seafood. William-Harrison Imports, Manassas, Va. Very Good. About $16.
The venerable house of Joseph Drouhin offers a Saint-Véran 2005 that’s unusually bright and lively, with lemon, lime and pear
scents and flavors etched with beguiling notes of clove and ginger. The wine is very dry and crisp, quite earthy and minerally, and so pure and intense that it feels crystalline. The finish is stony, steely and austere. Imported by Dreyfus, Ashby & Co, New York. Very Good+. About $12.50-$16.
Saint-Véran, to touch on geographical matters, lies in the southernmost reaches of Burgundy, between Mâconnais and Beaujolais. Only the chardonnay grape is allowed. The wines are best consumed within one to three years of the vintage. Pouilly-Fuissé, which produces wines of greater character and longevity, is a separate appellation within Saint-Véran.
January 11th, 2008 at 7:05 pm
I tried the Cave de Prissé in July and loved it. It goes great with fresh summer vegetables. Only a few more months to wait!
I’m trying to drink more–and better–whites in 2008. Burgundy is a great place to start.
January 11th, 2008 at 11:07 pm
Let’s hear it for St-Veran. Or indeed any Chardonnay that is allowed to speak for itself. Thanks for the tips, M. Koeppel.
January 12th, 2008 at 5:53 pm
De rien, M. Hughes.
Benito, Burgundy is indeed a great place to start drinking better white wines, especially with the 2005 vintage.
January 18th, 2008 at 1:39 am
Mr, Koeppel, I hope that, for all of our sakes, the dollar stops falling against the Euro so we can continue to enjoy great French wines without paying dearly for it!
Also, how did you choose the 12 bottles for your case? Tough choice! Most California wines lack that great minerality. I don’t want everything to taste like butterscotch and pineapple…
January 19th, 2008 at 6:23 pm
Hey, Kimberly, we’ve missed you. I agree about the dollar and the euro. If the euro doesn’t stop trouncing the dollars, we’ll never get back to the Old World.
I chose those 12 wines to reflect some diversity in grapes and styles and regions at not unreasonable prices. I mean choosing 12 wines about of 1000s is totally arbitrary, and if I did the same thing tomorrow, they would be all different wines.
Some California chardonnays that have that “great minerality” are Cakebread, Grgich Hills, Morgan’s Metallico, Bass-Porter (v. limited) and Girard.
January 21st, 2008 at 1:10 am
I’ve missed reading! I blame work for the absence, but I’ve got myself caught up after taking a couple of evenings to putter around the house…
Choosing a best-of for this is just maddening, I’m sure! But I’m right there with you on Grgich and Cakebread, and will go search for the others in the near future.
I’m currently enamored with Mer Soleil’s “Silver” (spectacularly refreshing) and Talbott’s Cuvee Carlotta…also wanting to get my hands on Macari “Early Wine” Chard. Not enough time in a day…
January 21st, 2008 at 11:23 pm
I forgot about “Silver” … I love that wine (but if only it were a little cheaper; why does a wine with no oak have to be as expensive as a wine WITH oak?????)
January 22nd, 2008 at 2:52 pm
Haha…Good question! Perhaps it’s because of who’s behind it? (Would any part of the Caymus owners’ family tree do things on the cheap?)
Or maybe limestone-based cement for tanks is more expensive than any of us thought…